Grief is hard, but grieving alone can be a torment of anguish. So we sit with the broken, we stay silent, and we sit Shiva with the tears.
Quick answer: Sitting Shiva is the Jewish practice of a seven-day mourning period after a burial, when friends and family visit the bereaved at home to offer comfort. Its heart is presence, not words. Whatever your faith, you can “sit Shiva” with a grieving friend by showing up, staying quiet, listening, and resisting the urge to fix, advise, or explain away their loss.
In this post:
- What is sitting Shiva?
- Job’s friends sat Shiva for seven days
- Giving attention to the loss
- What not to say to someone grieving
- A time to heal
When my father cried loud and hard, I experienced a kind of solidarity in my grief. A child had died, and a funeral was held. I placed a small, small casket into a tiny hole. It’s still there now.
Friends and family gathered and shared the loss. Yet it still catches me whenever I drive past the resting place of one who never drew breath. I’ve written more about that loss in The Slow Dance of Grief: Passing Through What Was.
Life in this broken world can hand you questions and harshness that no answers can satisfy.
There is a time for everything.
But some people don’t know the times and the seasons for being quiet and sitting with brokenness. To sit with the sorrow of loss.
What Is Sitting Shiva?
In the Jewish tradition, part of the “time for everything” is to sit Shiva.
I am not Jewish and have not experienced it myself, but here is what I have learned. Shiva (Hebrew for “seven”) is the week-long mourning period observed for a parent, sibling, spouse, or child. It begins after the burial. Mourners remain at home, and friends and family come to them to offer condolences and comfort. Traditionally, mourners tear an outer garment (a ritual called keriah) and wear it through the week.
The practice, as the Wikipedia article on Shiva in Judaism describes it, formalizes the natural way a person confronts grief. It gives room to express sorrow, talk about the person who has died, and slowly re-enter everyday life.
It dates back to biblical times. Joseph mourned his father Jacob for seven days (Genesis 50).
In the book of Job, we also find an example.
Job’s Friends Sat Shiva for Seven Days
Job’s suffering was too great for words. But we soon find that after sitting Shiva, they found their words, and they weren’t words of comfort.
For seven days, though, the friends got it right. They were in deep community with Job. They embraced the pain as if it were their own. Lavish attention was given to the soul of their friend. They watched with him when the load was too heavy.
Giving Attention to the Loss
Where have you experienced loss?
It may be the death of a loved one, but it could also be the loss of a dream, a marriage, a business, your health, or a special relationship. Some losses, like the ambiguous loss of estrangement, come with no funeral at all. Loss and death can come to us in so many ways. But has the Shiva been done?
I think in Western culture, we don’t grieve well. In my culture of European heritage, we have the funeral, and then all is supposedly done. There is an expectation of getting back into life.
Sure it hurts, but you are supposedly meant to shake it off and make the best of it. Nobody comes and sits Shiva with you for seven days.
No one gives attention to the deepest pain one experiences when the relationship is gone beyond grasp. No one sits and weeps.
Being alone is “not good” (Genesis 2:18), and that is why God created a helper. Someone to give attention to the soul of another.
What Not to Say to Someone Grieving
Some wise advice comes from Jewish Funerals U.S.A.
And sometimes there aren’t any. Here are examples of things not to say:
- “How are you?” (They’re not so good.)
- “I know how you feel.” (No, you don’t. Each person feels a unique loss.)
- “At least she lived a long life.” (Longer would have been better.)
- “It’s good that you have other children,” or, “Don’t worry, you’ll have more.” (The loss of a child, no matter what age, is completely devastating.)
- “Cheer up – in a few months, you’ll meet someone new.” (He or she has just lost the other half of their soul!)
- “Let’s talk about happy things.” (Maybe later.)
And please don’t F.A.S.S. – Fix, Advise, Save or Set straight. When you notice someone’s eyes start to fill, you are standing on sacred ground, so linger and listen.
This is the season to restore in a spirit of gentleness and to bear another’s burdens. To represent the “with you” of God.
A Time to Heal
A time to heal, a time to build, a time to laugh, a time to dance, a time to embrace, a time to mend, a time to speak, and a time to love.
There is a time for everything, and you can’t rush time. Some losses will take more time than others to process. There is no fixed, prescribed allotment for you to “get over it.”
The loss will come in waves. Little things trigger the loss to reignite. That’s okay. It’s normal. It’s being human. Sometimes the tears flow freely, and sometimes the tears won’t come at all.
In this time of grief, we need others to express love simply by their presence and solidarity. It may come through a few words, but they will always carry a sense of “I am with you, and I’m not going to leave you alone.”
Grief is hard, but grieving alone can be a torment of anguish, so we sit with the broken, stay silent, and give attention.
If grief ever becomes so heavy that you have thoughts of hurting yourself, please tell someone you trust today, or talk to your GP. In New Zealand you can call or text 1737, the free national helpline, any time.
Quotes to Consider
- Attention is the rarest and purest form of generosity. We have to try to cure our faults by attention and not by will. Simone Weil
- No one person can fulfill all your needs. But the community can truly hold you. The community can let you experience the fact that, beyond your anguish, there are human hands that hold you and show you God’s faithful love. Henri Nouwen
- There are two things that draw us outside of ourselves: pain on other people’s faces; and the unbelievable beauty that is other human beings at their best. Or in other words: cross and resurrection. Richard Rohr, Job and the Mystery of Suffering
- We are saved by those whom we go to save, and both of us are then saved in spite of ourselves. There is a mysterious “third” who is doing the saving. Suffering for and with the other seems to be the only way we know that our lives are not about us. Richard Rohr, Job and the Mystery of Suffering
Questions to Consider
- What would it be like for some friends to come and be with you in your loss?
- Death is an obvious example of loss, but what other examples can you think of? What losses have you experienced?
- Attention is the rarest and purest form of generosity, according to Simone Weil. How does generosity express itself in being silent in the face of loss?
Frequently Asked Questions
What does sitting Shiva mean?
Sitting Shiva is the seven-day Jewish mourning period that follows a burial. Mourners stay at home while friends and family visit to comfort them. More broadly, it describes offering quiet, attentive presence to someone who is grieving.
Can Christians sit Shiva with someone?
The formal ritual belongs to Judaism, but its heart is found throughout Scripture. Job’s friends sat with him in silence for seven days, and Joseph mourned his father for seven days. Anyone can follow that example by being present with a grieving friend.
What should I say to someone who is grieving?
Often, very little. Your presence says “I am with you” more clearly than advice or explanations. Avoid comparisons, silver linings, and attempts to fix the loss. Listen, stay, and let them set the pace.
Further Reading
- Why Can’t I Cry? Grief, Numbness, and the God Who Wipes Away Tears — Can’t cry after a loss? Grief can numb us. Discover why tears get stuck and how God gently meets you there.
- The Slow Dance of Grief: Passing Through What Was — Grief is the full-body experience of processing what was. Explore how to navigate loss, the stages of grief, and finding hope in God.
- Who Will Wipe Away My Tears? — Discover comfort in your pain. Explore how God meets us in our tears with gentleness, making all things new through divine compassion.
- Listen. You’re on Sacred Ground — When a tear forms, you’re on sacred ground. Discover why “taking off your sandals” and listening is more powerful than any fix or solution.
- Is The Load Too Heavy? Watch With Me — When the load of life is too heavy, you don’t have to carry it alone. Learn the power of “watching with” someone in their darkest hour.
- Coping with Ambiguous Loss by Estrangement — Learn to navigate the “ambiguous loss” of estrangement. Discover paths to healing and self-forgiveness when a loved one leaves without closure
About the Author
Since 1995, Barry Pearman has worked as a mental health support worker, community chaplain, and pastor, and has walked through depression himself. His training includes SoulCare Foundations under Dr Larry Crabb, a Bachelor of Applied Theology, spiritual direction training, and certificates in CBT interventions, pastoral therapy, and integrated mental health care. Turning the Page offers a grace-filled path to mental wholeness through faith and hope.
Photo by Harli Marten on Unsplash