A Grace-Filled Path to Mental Wholeness
Person feeling like a failure, and how to help them with grace

‘I’m Such a Failure’: How to Help Someone Stuck in a Failure Mindset

When You Feel Like a Failure

If you’ve never quietly said ‘I’m such a failure’ about yourself, then you will most likely have heard it from someone else.

This post is to help you help others who struggle with a failure mindset.

For myself, I can so easily personalise my failures into ‘I’m a failure’.

And look, I’m not trying to get sympathy or have a pity party. I’m not being a Poor Little Old Me (breaking free from self-pity and the victim mentality). It’s a thinking rut that I and many others slide into with devastating ease.

I try to do the right thing. I aim for a goal but never seem to quite hit the bullseye.

Actually, the word ‘never’ is probably not right. It feels like ‘never’. Along the way, I do have successes. I don’t always fail.

However, if I don’t address this failure mindset, then the thinking rut will just get deeper and longer. Pretty soon, any activity I engage in will come with the expectation of failure.

“Though you fail, you are not a failure, unless you fail to learn something from it.” – David Riddell

The brain, as Dr Rick Hanson says, takes its shape from what the mind rests upon. If you are dwelling and ruminating on failure messages, then those patterns are just going to get stronger and stronger.

How to Help Someone Who Feels Like a Failure

Here is what someone stuck in a failure mindset might want to say to you.

  • Help me aim at things that I can do. I am not you or anyone else, so please help me find my unique level of performance. Please don’t play the comparison game; it will only result in frustration and inner turmoil for everyone involved.
  • Help me discover what I can learn from those failings.
  • Praise every effort I make. Even when I fail, I will have achieved some things, and those need to be acknowledged and treated as stepping-stone successes. Be a champion who notices my progress.
  • Help me focus on the success of learning something new from the failure.
  • Watch your body language. That critical, dismissive eye combined with waving hands, sighing and so on just reinforces failure messages to me.
  • Remind me of the successes I have had. Show me photos of when I have succeeded. My brain really enjoys images.
  • Don’t give me trite sayings like ‘Better luck next time’.
  • Don’t take my failings as your failings. I have to take responsibility for the choices and decisions I make.
  • Please don’t rescue me. Help me, support me, encourage me, but please never do something for me that I could and should be doing for myself.
“The more you dwell on the negative, the more accustomed your brain becomes to dwelling on the negative.” – Rick Hanson

Thinking ‘I am a failure’ is a very easy rut to fall into. It’s like your thoughts are all okay, and then suddenly something happens and shoves you into this gluggy, mud-filled rut of being a failure.

So remind me of the ladder rung insights I can use to pull myself out once again.

7 Ladder Rung Insights for Climbing Out of a Failure Mindset

  1. I am neither my failures nor my successes. I am loved by God, and this love never fails.
  2. The truest love keeps no record of wrongs (failures). 1 Corinthians 13:5
  3. Jesus lived life to the full with those who were considered failures by others.
  4. Even when people failed Jesus, he had a plan of restoration. Think of Peter, Paul and the Prodigal Son.
  5. Our failings are God’s invitation to closer connection and some serious personal learning.
  6. Grace is at the heart of deep change (Roger Heuser). God gives me grace, and I will give grace to my own failures.
  7. Progress is made through having failures. Risk nothing, gain nothing. Keep going.

So, are you a failure? Only if you choose to see yourself in this way.

Quotes on Failure to Consider

Questions for Reflection

Answer these questions in the comments below, or leave an anonymous response.

  1. What have you learnt from your failures?
  2. What can we learn from people in the Bible about failure?
  3. Which of the 7 insights above spoke to you most deeply?

Keep Reading


About the author

Since 1995, Barry Pearman has worked as a mental health support worker, community chaplain, and pastor, and has walked through depression himself. His training includes SoulCare Foundations under Dr Larry Crabb, a Bachelor of Applied Theology, spiritual direction training, and certificates in CBT interventions, pastoral therapy, and integrated mental health care. Turning the Page offers a grace-filled path to mental wholeness through faith and hope.

Image: Claude Piché

Get the map. Take the steps. Add your email address. Check your inbox for the Welcome email and all your ebooks and courses 🙂

Join our newsletter